Sister blog of Physicists of the Caribbean. Shorter, more focused posts specialising in astronomy and data visualisation.
Wednesday 10 February 2016
Behold, the disc that doesn't do anything !
Well, not very much at any rate. It definitely does not explode or disintegrate. It does make some rather nice rings, but that's OK. I don't need (or expect) it to be perfectly stable - not exploding is all I ask.
This one is embedded in a dark matter halo. I don't have a script to convert the dark matter particles into a format I can display but I'll try and get one.
A number of failed attempts proceeded this one, even with the dark matter. I tried spherical clouds first, which worked well at low masses but not at high masses. With a spherical system the gas is supported by its temperature, which for a massive cloud has to be extremely high. That means an extremely high pressure, which I think was tending to blast things apart.
With a disc, the support comes from rotation much more than pressure. So the gas can be cool and is far less prone to expanding. I also used a lower mass of gas than in the previous runs. With a pure gas disc that would have meant the rotation speed would also have been lower, making it difficult to judge if it was really stable against rotation without doing a very long simulation. Anyway I need a higher rotation speed to match the observations.
With the dark matter, I don't need to worry about finding a sweet spot in terms of being hot enough to avoid collapse but not so hot it explodes. It's bound by the mass of the dark matter, not the gas - so if I make it hotter, it doesn't matter so much. A lot of instabilities caused by making it colder are also avoided - there's less differential rotation across the disc because the extra mass changes the rotation curve.
This isn't quite the disc I need - it needs a bit more dark matter, be a bit smaller, spin a bit faster, and the gas needs to be a bit hotter. But it's very close. With luck, by next week I should be able to chuck this into a galaxy cluster and watch the carnage (or lack thereof).
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Red, dead, but very well-fed
What stops galaxies from forming stars ? Normally I'm most interested in this for objects which have hardly any stars at all : ultra dif...
-
In the last batch of simulations, we dropped a long gas stream into the gravitational potential of a cluster to see if it would get torn...
-
Of course you can prove a negative. In one sense this can be the easiest thing in the world : your theory predicts something which doesn...
-
Another day, another paper on how exciting Ultra Diffuse Galaxies are. At first, these large, faint galaxies were just wholly unexpected, a...
Nice! What kind of equipment are you using for crunching the numbers?
ReplyDeleteRhys Taylor You're attempting to model a stellar system accretion disc birth, right?
ReplyDeleteSakari Maaranen Thanks ! No special hardware here, just an ordinary desktop. 16 GB RAM, 3.2 GHz i7 processor. We have a computer cluster downstairs, but it's not needed for this. Simulations take ~2 hours to run, though that varies by a factor of a few.
ReplyDeletePaul McIntyre Nope, a galactic disc.
ReplyDeleteIt might be more interesting if you dyed the dark matter brighter. How about hot pink? Everybody knows divine fingers are pink as a piglet!
ReplyDeleteso the dark matter is outside? What about the center, the cluster is strange?
ReplyDeleteAndres Soolo Tim Stoev In fact since I don't have a script to plot the positions of the dark matter particles I have no idea what it's doing. It should be in a cloud of the same size of the disc. At least it is initially, but what it does as the simulation evolves I have no idea.
ReplyDeleteAs soon as I get the dark matter plotted, I'll be sure to make it bright luminous pink.
A new study is shedding pink light to dark matter. In a groundbreaking simulation experiment tomorrow, scientists are evolving a new model of dark matter involving what they describe as a 'bright luminous pink' element. To be continued...
ReplyDelete